Well, I've seen several of his deals, including, on a regrettably bored and forlorn late afternoon-evening, Year One. Of course, I disliked him from the instant I saw him, so I guess I still fall into that mold.
Nah, that's entirely fair. Like I said, it's just the people who do it because it's trendy, they piss me off.
Hipsterish is like emo, it means whatever you want it to me in a vague, undefined sense.
It was based on a hipsterish comic book, anyway.
I don't think that's valid - I mean, yeah, emo - as an example - can mean whatever you want, but it's not like you're going to call the happy, socially and academically successful jock who listens to hip-hop and has no significant personal problems an emo, it's the kid with few friends, listening to My Chemical Romance alone in their room, with the goth-ish clothing, writing shitty poetry about pain and suffering, then scratching themselves for attention and calling it cutting, that who you'd call emo. If you distill down to the shared properties of the people you call Emo, you come to a decent definition.
As for the comic book - Well, it wasn't really hipsterish, again. It lacked everything that one would think of as the properties of a hipster work, other than that it wasn't mainstream, until you consider the medium - In the comic book world, it was VERY mainstream, some seriously hot property. Again, I don't think it's hipsterish, and really, if you apply the definition too broadly, you end up with a useless definition.
It's like the world "Troll" on the internet, now, if you want an example - It's essentially useless and pointless, because where once it was people deliberately fishing for a negative reaction, throwing out bait and dragging it along, and seeing who bites, it's now just generally used on damn near anyone who disagrees with someone, especially if the person being disagreed with is the one holding the majority opinion.
Again - I'm not saying you have to LIKE the movie, I mean, I loved it and even I had my problems with it. However, it really just isn't hipsterish at all.